Atlee Copied These Films To Make Jawan??
Written by keerthiga Published on Sep 09, 2023 | 06:55 AM IST | 303
In the world of cinema, inspiration often walks a fine line between homage and imitation. Recently, Shah Rukh Khan’s latest release, “Jawan,” directed by Atlee, has found itself at the center of a swirling controversy. Some ardent moviegoers and netizens have raised questions about the film’s originality, drawing comparisons to various South Indian films like “Kaththi,” “Aarambam,” “Mersal,” and even international hits like “Money Heist.” With claims of similar scenes and thematic elements, it’s time to delve deeper into this debate and explore whether “Jawan” truly lacks originality or if it’s a creative amalgamation of the director’s past work.
“Jawan” made headlines for all the right reasons, storming the box office with a record-breaking opening. Director Atlee, known for his successes in the Tamil film industry, made his Hindi debut with this film, marking a significant milestone in his career. The film’s remarkable earnings of ₹129 crore worldwide underscore its undeniable appeal among audiences. However, the echoes of déjà vu and familiarity have led some fans to question whether Atlee may have borrowed a bit too liberally from his previous projects.
One of the most striking observations made by critics and fans alike is the presence of recurring elements in “Jawan” that bear resemblance to scenes and themes from South Indian films. Slow-motion sequences, computer-generated effects, and flashbacks are some of the cinematic techniques that have left viewers wondering about the film’s originality. Critics argue that Atlee may have relied on these tried-and-tested formulae, potentially diluting the novelty factor of “Jawan.”
The comparisons with films like “Kaththi,” “Aarambam,” and “Mersal” are hard to ignore. While there’s nothing inherently wrong with a filmmaker revisiting successful themes or techniques, it’s crucial to strike a balance between familiarity and innovation. Some viewers believe that “Jawan” leans too heavily on these influences, which can hinder the audience’s ability to connect with the film on a deeper level.
Moreover, the comparisons don’t end with South Indian cinema. The international hit series “Money Heist” has also found itself in the discussion, with viewers pointing out parallels in certain scenes. While it’s not uncommon for filmmakers to draw inspiration from various sources, it raises questions about the extent to which such inspiration should be used. After all, originality is often what sets a film apart and makes it memorable.
On the other side of the debate, Atlee’s defenders argue that the director’s talent lies in his ability to skillfully blend elements from his previous works to create something new and engaging. They believe that even if “Jawan” bears similarities to other films, Atlee’s vision and execution make it a unique cinematic experience.
Supporters of Atlee contend that the director’s familiarity with these techniques allows him to use them effectively, adding depth and resonance to his storytelling. They argue that Atlee’s track record of delivering box office hits is a testament to his understanding of what appeals to audiences. In their eyes, his films may draw inspiration from various sources, but they always come together as a coherent and compelling narrative.
Checkout the Reactions:
— கார்த்திக் (@Rajofficial152) September 8, 2023
If any other south hero did jawan.. Flop aagirukkum.. https://t.co/m82DG6MrjY
— Prasanna (@tweetngrose) September 9, 2023
Flashback intro gusthi fight- Mersal copy
Climax dialogue – Sarkar copy
Bus fight- Valimai copy
Opening fight- 7am arivu copy
Farmer suicide – Kaththi copy
Srk and daughter scene – YA copy
Desa droghi scene – Villu, Sardar
Kidnap n kill -Mersal
200 ruba ku 40 padam kaatitaan🙏 https://t.co/uLGTJAYQWH
— Tharun🦁 (@officialtharun_) September 9, 2023
These Cine blue thees.
Atlee eduthathu oru Hindi movie.. Inga work aana scenes ah angayum semaya present panirukaru pola..
Intha scenes lam nammala epdi excite pannucho athe magic than ipo #Jawan paathu anga sillaraya sedhara vitutu irukanga..
Atlee knows what he is doing.. https://t.co/Xlu8DXk0eQ
— GunaAdhithyan (@TheriGunaa) September 8, 2023
Idhelaam paathadhukku aprom kooda Inuma da muttu kudukuringa Atlee ku💀
Idhuve Aamai oda padathula vandhurinda appo mattum copy nu koovuradhu 💀 https://t.co/F2VGdAJL3U
— Mohnish Maadhav (@__maddyyyyy__) September 8, 2023
Furthermore, Atlee’s fans emphasize that his foray into Hindi cinema is a significant milestone for both the director and the industry. It represents a fusion of talent from different regions of India, which can lead to a richer and more diverse cinematic landscape. They believe that Atlee’s success in “Jawan” paves the way for more collaborations and cross-cultural exchanges in the world of filmmaking.
Amir Revealed His Marriage Plan With Pavni!!Oct 06, 2023
This Young Vijay TV Star To Act In Thalaivar 170 !!Oct 05, 2023
Chinmayi Met With Accident Due To A Drunk Driver??Oct 04, 2023
Actor Siddharth Got Emotional On Stage!! Watch VideoOct 04, 2023